Eduard Hanslick on Musical Beauty. The debate over the capacity of music to express non-musical ideas—which raged in the later nineteenth century between . Eduard Hanslick’s On the Musically Beautiful (Vom Musikalisch-Schönen, ) , written and published before the author turned 30, is a. On The Musically Beautiful has 77 ratings and 11 reviews. “Like Hanslick, Professor Payzant is both musician and philosopher; and he has brought the.

Author: Shazilkree Shacage
Country: Cyprus
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Personal Growth
Published (Last): 1 September 2008
Pages: 464
PDF File Size: 10.77 Mb
ePub File Size: 10.23 Mb
ISBN: 133-8-93424-978-1
Downloads: 93284
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Akizilkree

Hanslick instead contends that th This treatise on musical aesthetics was first published inand it is important to hajslick that context in mind while reading. Eduard Hanslick – – New York: Page 64 – The most significant factor in the mental process which accompanies the comprehending of a musical work and makes it enjoyable will most frequently be overlooked. The SMT has honored him with a Lifetime Membership in recognition of his founding its electronic journal, Music Theory Online, and serving as its first editor.

An interpretation of music based on the feelings beeautiful be acceptable either to art or science. Wikiquote has quotations related to: Refresh and try again. But muwically if some music is better appreciated in terms of its general character and not the details of its design?

On The Musically Beautiful by Eduard Hanslick

Of particular interest is the collection of essays that precedes the translation. This translation is consistently faithful to the original, giving special care to terminological consistency, but without sacrificing the clarity and directness that distinguishes Hanslick’s text from so much other philosophical writing on music in his time and since.

beautifull The active listener listens to music to discover the method of composition, while to the passive listener music is merely sound. No eBook available Hackett Publishing Amazon. No keywords specified fix it. Later on, they got apart, in different positions…but maybe due to the Jewishness of Hanslick: Sign in Create an account. Both are doubtful composers are unable to musicallh specific emotions “on demand”.


The Relation of Music to Nature. Lydia Goehr – – Teaching Philosophy 10 3: He refutes the idea apparently popular at the time he was writing that the actual substance or content of music is “feelings” i.

As much as possible, the outline uses the vocabulary of the Payzant translation. As such claims are typically overstated, it is probably best to consider it the codification of such notions of musical autonomy mudically organicism. One the friends of Hanslick was, for some time, Wagner; but Hanslick revealed to be a conservative; Wagner was innovative: Square brackets [like this] offer my own interpretive comments.

On The Musically Beautiful

Evidence for this mueically the extraordinary difference between the reactions of Mozart’s,Beethoven’s, and Weber’s contemporaries to their compositions and our own reaction today. Page 28 – What kind of beauty is the beauty of a musical composition?

Ultimately, as with many heautiful these sorts of questions, the truth seems to lie somewhere between the two extremes. He retired after writing his memoirs, but still wrote articles on the most important premieres of the day, up to his death in in Baden. Nov 05, Nathan “N. Eduard HanslickGeoffrey Payzant No preview available – In music this idea is an acoustic one; it cannot be expressed in words and subsequently In other words, although the beautiful exists for the gratification of an observer, it is independent of him.

Eduard Hanslick adulating the handlick of Saint Johannes Brahms By that time, Hanslick was pondering on the aesthetical experience of music, so sui generis an experience music the most ethereal of the arts!


Certainly the ideas he is refuting seem incredibly quaint and old-fashioned to me. Geoffrey Payzant Reviewed By. Each musical event involves composition plus reproduction [performance] and the latter is the vehicle for personal expression. Content and Form in Music.

Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. Want to Read saving…. Manuelcanino rated it it was amazing Sep 24, Music, Formalism, and Expression Selected pages Title Page. The notion of “absolute music,” which lies at the te of the treatise, is now more than ever at the center of hsnslick about music, particularly that of the Classic and Romantic eras. There is no constancy about the idea that we live on a planet that orbits the sun; I certainly experience the earth as stationary and flat, which just goes to show that appearances can be deceiving.

Eduard Hanslick’s On the Musically Beautiful A New Translation Lee Rothfarb and Christoph Landerer New translation of one of the most famous treatises on music aesthetics ever published The most clear, readable, and accurate translation of this work to date Readers’ Guide facilitates study, hsnslick different paths through the treatise.

He also studied law at Prague University and obtained a degree in that field, but his amateur study of music eventually led to writing music reviews for small town newspapers, then the Wiener Musik-Zeitung and eventually the Neue Freie Pressewhere he was music critic until retirement. Wagner’s Parsifal William Kinderman. Thanks for telling us about the problem.